Should you transfer out of a defined benefit pension?

Defined benefit pensions

he pensions world is in crisis, partly because of changing regulations, partly because of bad management, but mainly because we’re all living longer – and we all need more money to keep us going through our longer retirements.

This means older-style final salary pensions (also known as defined benefit pensions) are being phased out, leaving defined contribution pensions as the pensions scheme of choice. Should you transfer out of a defined benefit pension?

Defined benefit vs. defined contribution

They’re the two main pension types, so here’s a quick recap of what they mean:

— Defined contribution pension
The most common form of pension scheme. Money paid in by you or your employer is used to invest in shares and other assets with the aim of increasing the value of your pension. The amount you get back depends on the performance of the investments over time.

— Defined benefit pension
Usually set up by your employer, the pensions are based on your length of service, salary and the scheme’s own rules and calculations. The amount you receive at retirement will be guaranteed by your employer (hence ‘defined benefit’). But many employers are struggling to honour the payments.

The defined benefit black hole

Many companies have realised that final salary pensions, while great for employees, aren’t great for their own bank balances. You’ve probably read the headlines: there’s a huge black hole in the UK’s collective defined benefit pension fund, with a deficit estimated to be around £197bn. The final salary promise – a promise of constant annual income no matter how long you live – has become too difficult to keep.

As a result, defined benefit pensions are dropping like flies; so it’s possible your employer will offer you a transfer out.

Should I transfer out of a defined benefit scheme?

Despite all the negative press around defined benefit pension schemes, it’s important to know that not everyone will benefit from transferring out of their employer’s defined benefit pension scheme. But you might consider it if you:

  • Have alternative sources of retirement income (other than the pension)
  • Are unmarried and don’t have any dependants
  • Would like a more flexible income stream during your retirement
  • Would like to invest your pension funds elsewhere
  • Have lower than usual life expectancy, perhaps due to ill health

Sounds like me – how do I get started?

As an employee, you have the right to request something called a ‘transfer value calculation’ once a year for free. This offer is essentially a lump sum paid to you in order to transfer out and relieve them of the financial burden of the pension. Once you have this in writing, you have three months to either accept of decline the offer.

Here’s an example

David, 55, is married with three grown up children. He works at a large international insurance firm where he’s held senior positions for nearly 20 years.

David has a final salary/defined benefit pension, and his employer has offered him a transfer value of £1m. As this amount is well above the government’s £30,000 threshold, by law he needs to seek advice from an independent financial advisor.

The offer looks very attractive and could enable David to take early retirement or start working part-time instead, but he’s not sure of the right decision. He needs a comprehensive pension review and a recommendation on what to do next – but he doesn’t have much time: the 3-month window will close and the £1m offer could slip away.

Seeking independent financial advice

Here at Flying Colours, we’ve crafted our processes to give a recommendation in as little time as possible. What’s more, our team of experts have a combined 100+ years of pensions and investments experience, advising on final salary schemes and transfer offers for FTSE 100 and 250 companies like Barclays, Aviva, HSBC, Tata, and Rolls-Royce. And we’re highly competitive on costs.

Get in touch

If, like David, you’re considering a transfer out of your existing defined benefit pension or your employer has contacted you to make an offer, contact Flying Colours today for sound independent financial advice. Call us today on 0333 241 9900.

or see how we can help with your defined benefit transfer scheme, here.


We hope you find the education zone interesting and useful, but please remember it shouldn’t be viewed as financial advice.